You type “Rolex Datejust II review” because you want something simple: to know if you’re going to regret it. Normal.
The Datejust II is an “in-between” model. Between the classic Datejust (more sensible) and the Datejust 41 (more accomplished, more modern). And since Rolex discontinued the Datejust II after a few years, it becomes a typical hunting ground: not infinite supply, identifiable references, and price variations that give you the impression of a good deal... until you dig.
Small detail that counts: it has a real presence on the wrist because it is thicker than a Datejust 41. It's not “huge” on paper, but when worn, you can feel it (yes, even under a slightly fitted shirt).
You see the word “chunky” thrown around everywhere. And it's rarely explained.
Basically: the Datejust II appears more massive, more “square” in proportions, where the Datejust 41 has a more refined silhouette. Some love it because it gives a chic tool-watch look, others find it a bit… clumsy. I don't know where you stand (and frankly, it changes in a second when you have it in front of you).
But there is a real benefit: on an average to large wrist, a Datejust II looks less “jewelry” and more “watch”. And that, for certain styles, is exactly the goal.
If you want to compare this brand philosophy with another house (and avoid going in circles), I have a paper that lays the foundations: Rolex or Breitling: clear, complete comparative guide.
We're not going to pretend: if you're hesitating between Datejust II vs Datejust 41, you're especially hesitating between two generations.
The Datejust II runs with the caliber 3136 (a solid, proven basis), with a typical power reserve of around 48 hours. The Datejust 41 takes on board the caliber 3235 and its longer reserve (often given around 70 hours). In real life? This means a watch that better supports “off days” without falling apart in terms of time setting. Simple. Obvious.
On paper, it's subtle. In fact, you feel it.
The Datejust II is often given around 12.17mm thick, the Datejust 41 around 11.70mm. This half-millimeter doesn't seem like much... but it's exactly the kind of detail that makes a watch “hang” a bit more under the sleeve. And as a result, you see her more. You don't feel it anymore. Some people want that. Others don't.
Another point: the Datejust 41 has a wider variety of configurations (straps, bezels, dials). The Datejust II is more limited. And paradoxically… that can be good news. Fewer weird combinations, fewer “custom” temptations, more overall coherence.
But if you absolutely want the perfect mix (Jubilee + fluted + specific dial), the Datejust 41 makes your life easier. So.
There Rolex Datejust II 116300it is the simplest to assume. Steel, smooth bezel, clean look. You can wear it with jeans, a shirt, a blazer. That works. And it avoids the “too Rolex” effect that some people don't accept on a daily basis (yes, it's a subject, even if no one says it).
And above all: it gives you the 41 mm format without forcing you to like the fluted bezel. If you're unsure about this detail, start here. Really.
There Rolex Datejust II 116334 brings back the symbol: the fluted bezel in white gold. It’s the historical nod, the thing that makes “Datejust” at first glance. If you want a Datejust II that looks like a Rolex… without explanation… this is often the best entry point.
But be careful: fluted + 41 mm + more marked thickness, it makes the whole thing more demonstrative. Great if you assume. Less if you want to remain discreet.
There Rolex Datejust II 116333 (steel + yellow gold), it’s an atmosphere. It catches the light, it “warms up” visually, it gives a more jewel-like presence. If you like yellow gold, you'll love it. If you are more of a sober steel type, you risk getting tired quickly.
And a point that many discover too late: the Rolesor has an impact on the purchase price, but also on your potential resale (smaller audience, more distinct tastes). In short, it's a style choice, not just a line on a technical sheet.
Smooth bezel: more modern, cleaner, easier to wear every day.
Fluted bezel: more Rolex, more signature, more “visible luxury”.
And yes, it's that stupid. The rest is intellectual dressing.
A Datejust II, you don't buy it “by feeling”. Not at this budget level.
You first look for consistency : reference, dial, bracelet, bezel, year. Nothing should smack of opportunistic assembly. Then thestate : too polished case, soft edges, rinsed bracelet... these are signals that are expensive. And finally the papers / set : it doesn't make the watch better, but it makes the purchase more peaceful and the resale simpler.
“Revised”. “Controlled”. “Works perfectly”. Yes, okay. But when? By whom? With what as an invoice?
A serious revision is documented. Otherwise, you finance a future workshop visit. And there, immediately, your “good price” becomes average. I say that, I say nothing.
I'm not going to give you instructions for counterfeiters. Bad idea.
On the other hand, you can arm yourself with the right reflexes (salesman, traceability, consistency of elements, professional inspection). If you want a clear framework, I have a dedicated article: spotting a fake Rolex without being tricked.
The Datejust II is rated waterproof 100mbut that doesn’t mean “I dive in and forget”. Waterproofing is a story of joints, control, aging. If you want to swim with it often: have it checked. If you just want to survive the rain and everyday life: ok, don't worry.
On the market at the end of 2025, we come across many Datejust IIs in an area €7,000–10,000 (often higher in full set, or on very desired configurations). And yes, you can see below… but it's rarely “free”: average condition, no papers, aggressive polishing, vague seller, or not very liquid config.
And you will also see ads for 12,000+ on gem-set versions / rarer dials / very premium sellers. It exists. That doesn't mean it's your best move.
You have three “clean” scenarios.
Secure platform (marketplace type with buyer protection): you pay a little for peace of mind, but you reduce the risk of a basic scam. Read the conditions, especially returns and “certified”.
Recognized professional reseller : often more expensive, but more comprehensive (control, guarantee, history). Ideal if you want zero mental load.
Particular : It might be a good deal, but you're the safety net. If you don't know how to control, you delegate (expertise). Otherwise, you play poker.
Yes. Often, yes.
Because it ticks a lot of boxes: date, readability, robustness, reasonable comfort, style that goes from casual to dressy. It’s a “lifetime Rolex”, not a showcase item. And if you want a more “sporty” alternative from Rolex, the Submariner inevitably comes up in the discussion.
If you want to get an idea of the positioning (and why people keep coming back to it), read our detailed review of the Rolex Submariner.
The “big yes” comes when you know what you want.
You want a 41 mm Datejust which has a slightly more raw personality, a less “jewelry” presence, and you accept the 100% second-hand purchase with its verifications. There, the Datejust II is consistent. It is logical. It’s…obvious, even.
If you really want a finer, more modern Datejust, easier to configure: you'll end up with the Datejust 41. And you won't be unhappy. So why complicate your life?
So. No legend, no smoke and mirrors. Just a choice to make… and a choice to assume.
David Deteve — Editor (L’Swiss Made Watch). Method: cross-purchase analysis (manufacturer/guide characteristics, comparisons, observation of market ranges on resale platforms), consulted and updated on 12/13/2025.
Please share by clicking this button!
Visit our site and see all other available articles!